You Can Bank On Our Rates

The most local, national and online bank rates!

Another 1929? No, and Here's Why
The stock market bears some resemblance to the 1930s, but the policy response is vastly different.

By Vince Farrell Jr.

(Vince Farrell Jr. is chief investment officer for Soleil Securities Group and a contributor to and its subscription investor site RealMoney).

A lot of comparisons are being made about the current environment and the 1930s, resulting in even more fear and panic as an unthinkable repeat of that era seems possible. The action of the stock market bears some resemblance to the 1930s, but the policy response is vastly different.

The stock market fell 89% from peak to trough during the Great Depression. Oddly, there were ferocious rallies along the way. Of the 36 days in the last 80 years that saw the market rise 6% or more in a single day, 32 occurred between 1929 and 1933.

In terms of drops, from 1937 to 1941, the market fell 60%. Since then, the two worst bear markets were 1974-1975 and 2000 to 2002. Both were off about 48%.

In 1974, there were more stocks below $10 on the NYSE than above $10. At the intraday low last Friday, the S&P was off 50% from its peak last October. The snapback rally from Friday to Tuesday's intraday high was 1950 Dow points! Such market action has happened in all bear markets.

A peak-to-trough decline of 50% invariably makes you ask the question if this is the beginning of a cataclysmic economic collapse.

In the 1930s, the policy reactions were exactly wrong. The government delayed its response for too long, and the downturn was allowed to entrench itself. And the initial policy moves were incorrect. Money supply shrank by one-third between 1929 and 1933. The thought was to punish the Wall Street speculator and deny him credit for his evil manipulations. Tariffs were raised which chocked off international trade as reciprocal tariffs were imposed. Taxes also were raised.

Today the system is being flooded with liquidity. The Fed's balance sheet started the crisis at about $900 billion and will probably be close to $2 trillion by year's end. Central banks around the world are acting in concert to provide liquidity. The meeting of the G7 yielded a promise to "do no harm" to another nation with whatever your individual countries response was to be. And while taxes are likely to go up with a new administration, they are unlikely to reach the levels of the 1930s.

There was no unemployment insurance in the 1930s, so there was no net to catch the unemployed. Distrust between banks is the problem we face today, but in the Depression, check writing ground to a halt, and cash payments were the norm.

Ben Bernanke's economic background includes much study of the Great Depression. We might argue among ourselves about the speed of some of the policy responses, but the reaction to today's crisis is 180 degrees opposite to the 1930s.

Nobody ever made a dime by panicking, says Jim Cramer. Moneymaking opportunities exist despite the market turmoil. So where's a market master like Cramer putting his money these days? Check out his personal portfolio at Action Alerts PLUS. Take a free trial now.

green arrowFinancial Resources